How Do You Evaluate a Startup for Seed Funding?

How Do You Evaluate a Startup for Seed Funding?

How Do You Evaluate a Startup for Seed Funding?

In the quest to uncover what truly matters when evaluating a startup for seed funding, we’ve gathered insights from CEOs and co-founders. From assessing founder coachability and adaptability to understanding the importance of team dynamics in early-stage startups, explore the top nine key factors these seasoned professionals consider essential.

  • Founder Coachability and Adaptability
  • Business Model Realism and Viability
  • Founding Team’s Industry Expertise
  • Team Resilience as Success Indicator
  • Founder Passion and Investor Relations
  • Understanding and Determination of the Founding Team
  • Market Opportunity and Team Execution
  • Startup’s Relationship to Market Shifts
  • Team Importance in Early-Stage Startups

Founder Coachability and Adaptability

Coachability is a big one for me. I’ve always found that the founders who have the ability to listen, learn, and adapt are the ones that will end up doing the best in the long run because the market they operate in will be a completely different one every three years or so, at most.

Understanding where you’re going wrong, taking the time to learn from those who have been in the game for a longer time, and being willing and able to iterate on those ideas without letting your ego get in the way is a massive predictor of success in my book. Essentially, have a plan that makes sense on paper but be flexible enough to know when you need to pivot.

Kate KandeferKate Kandefer
CEO, SEOwind

Business Model Realism and Viability

The realism and viability of its business model are crucial. It’s vital to critically examine the underlying assumptions to ensure they are realistic and practical.

Metrics like DAU/MAU are useful for understanding user engagement, but they can sometimes give a skewed picture, if not properly interpreted. Similarly, LTV/CAC ratios, while informative, can often be too optimistic in the early stages of a startup.

The balance between hopeful projections and realistic timelines is key. A startup must be able to sustain itself financially until it can achieve its projected goals. This balanced viewpoint provides a more accurate method for evaluating a startup’s potential for success.

Tobias LiebschTobias Liebsch

Founding Team’s Industry Expertise

The strength of the individual members of the founding team—this, in my experience, is by far the best predictor of success or failure for a startup. A deep well of experience and expertise in the industry they are planning to enter means that they will have already considered the majority of the issues that might crop up as a new player and have thought of ways around them.

They’ll be much less likely to be caught by surprise and run into that singular issue that often seems to crop up for less experienced startups, which ends the business before it can truly begin to get its legs under it. A proven track record helps, but isn’t 100% necessary, so long as the skills and knowledge are there.

Dragos BadeaDragos Badea
CEO, Yarooms

Team Resilience as Success Indicator

The Resilience Quotient

When delving into seed-funding evaluation, I’ve found that the team’s resilience is the North Star. Let me share a real-life example: I encountered a startup with a groundbreaking idea, but they faced unexpected market shifts and initial setbacks. What set them apart was the team’s ability to pivot gracefully, learn from challenges, and stay committed to their vision.

Investors keenly observed how this team, instead of being deterred by obstacles, embraced them as opportunities for growth. Their resilience was evident in every pivot, strategic adjustment, and persistent pursuit of success. This experience taught me that beyond innovative concepts, it’s the team’s tenacity that truly defines a startup’s potential for seed-funding success. Resilience transforms stumbling blocks into stepping stones on the unpredictable journey of startup evolution.

Jon TorresJon Torres
CEO, Jon Torres

Founder Passion and Investor Relations

Based on my recent experience securing $3.75 million in seed funding for Automat and connecting with investors, I’ve come to understand that one crucial factor investors consider when evaluating a startup is the people behind it, first and foremost. Investors can tell a lot about a team by how they present their market size and product. But the most crucial person is the founder. The founder needs to be really passionate about their work and believe it can make people and businesses more effective, happy, and productive.

This is important because a founder’s passion and belief can drive a startup’s success and help overcome challenges. Their vision is key to inspiring the team and attracting customers.

Following the assessment of the people involved, investors consider the startup’s ideas and innovation, followed by an evaluation of the potential market. It’s worth noting that seed investors, especially those committed for the long term, value a strong and positive relationship with the entrepreneur. Effective communication, honesty, and consistency in building the company are vital aspects that can further strengthen the investor-founder partnership during the startup journey.

Lucas OchoaLucas Ochoa
Founder & CEO, Automat

Understanding and Determination of the Founding Team

Evaluating a startup for seed funding involves assessing the founding team’s expertise and passion. Investors seek a team with a deep understanding of the market and industry, as well as the determination to navigate the startup journey.

A passionate and knowledgeable team can effectively communicate their vision, instilling confidence in potential investors. This foundation often paves the way for long-term success and growth.

Gavin YiGavin Yi
CEO, Yijin Hardware

Market Opportunity and Team Execution

One important thing to think about when assessing a firm for seed funding is the market opportunity. Determining the viability of a business requires evaluating its target market size, growth potential, and competitive landscape. Startups with the ability to develop at a scalable rate and that meet a sizable market need attract investors.

It’s also critical to assess the startup’s team, their level of experience, and their capacity to carry out the plan. Success is more likely when there is a strong team with the ability to realize a clear vision. Investors can make well-informed decisions about seed funding by closely examining the startup’s employees and the market opportunity.

James OwenJames Owen
Co-Founder & Director, Click Intelligence

Startup’s Relationship to Market Shifts

A key, yet often under-emphasized, factor in evaluating a startup for seed funding is the startup’s adaptability and resilience in the face of market changes and challenges. While many investors focus on the typical metrics like market size, product innovation, and the team’s background, assessing a startup’s adaptability provides deep insights into its potential for long-term success.

Adaptability in a startup is reflected in its ability to pivot effectively when faced with unforeseen challenges or shifts in the market. For example, consider how many startups had to radically change their strategies during the COVID-19 pandemic. Those who quickly adapted by modifying their business models, leveraging new technologies, or tapping into emerging market needs were more likely to thrive. This ability to pivot is not just about surviving crises; it’s a critical trait for long-term growth in the ever-evolving business landscape.

When evaluating startups for seed funding, I look for evidence of this adaptability in their history. Have they evolved their product based on user feedback? How did they respond to any setbacks or market shifts? This evaluation goes beyond what’s presented in the pitch deck—it involves discussions about past challenges, strategic decisions, and the founders’ mindsets.

Bruno GavinoBruno Gavino
Founder, CEO, CodeDesign

Team Importance in Early-Stage Startups

After two decades of investing in early-stage startups, I’ve learned that the team is the most important factor I look at when evaluating a company for seed funding. At such an early stage, the idea can easily pivot or fail to gain traction, but with the right team that’s nimble, resourceful, and determined, they can adapt and find the right product-market fit.

I want to see that the founders are passionate about solving a real problem, but also open-minded enough to iterate based on customer feedback. Beyond raw talent, I look for founders who demonstrate resilience and are in it for the long haul. Building a startup is incredibly hard, so the team needs that grit, tenacity, and vision to power through the ups and downs.

Getting the right team in place early, with strong chemistry and complementary skills, is crucial—that’s the foundation upon which successful startups are built.

Noel GriffithNoel Griffith
CMO, SupplyGem

Submit Your Answer

Would you like to submit an alternate answer to the question, “What’s a key factor in evaluating a startup for seed funding?”

Submit your answer here.

Related Articles