How Will the Antitrust Ruling Against Google Reshape Search?
In the wake of a landmark antitrust ruling against Google, we’ve gathered insights from founders, CEOs, and other top executives to forecast the repercussions in the search industry. From the potential rise of niche search engines to the prediction that Google’s dominance will persist, here are seven expert takes on how the landscape may evolve.
- Rise of Niche Search Engines
- Competitors May Gain Market Share
- Advertisers Benefit From More Choices
- Local and Voice Search Optimization
- Google’s Dominance Likely to Persist
- Increased Competition in Digital Advertising
- Enhanced User Choice and Privacy
Rise of Niche Search Engines
The most recent antitrust decision that went against Google itself was a pivotal moment for the search industry. This landmark decision could set off seismic shifts in competition.
The deals with device manufacturers and browsers that have traditionally been exclusive are part of paying for Google Search (Safari alone can cost as much as $12 billion a year), but these agreements will likely see competition if the wind blows in this direction.
In the future, I see an explosion of vertical search engines that are targeting a particular industry or type of user going up. These specialized platforms will offer a more focused and relevant search experience.
Simon Brisk
Founder & SEO Strategist, Click Intelligence
Competitors May Gain Market Share
As CEO of a digital marketing agency, I expect this ruling to significantly impact how Google displays its own products in search. Google will likely have to downgrade how prominently it features services like Google Maps and YouTube in results. For over a decade, competitors have argued that Google unfairly promotes its own products.
This may embolden competitors like Microsoft and Amazon to pursue their own antitrust cases against Google’s dominance in search and ads. If Google has to demote its services, it could help competitors gain search market share. It may also push Google to find new revenue streams beyond ads, like paid subscriptions.
Long-term, the tech landscape will look very different. The antitrust ruling introduces many new variables that could reshape search as we know it. As an agency helping clients reach new customers, my team is closely following how this unfolds.
Nicole Farber
CEO, ENX2 Legal Marketing
Advertisers Benefit From More Choices
The antitrust ruling against Google could alter how search engines operate by breaking Google’s monopoly. This may open up the market for other search engines, promoting increased competition and diversity. One prediction is that advertisers might benefit from lower costs due to more ad-platform choices. With new competitors entering the scene, the pressure on Google to maintain its dominance could result in better advertising options and more innovative features, ultimately benefiting both consumers and businesses.
Shane McEvoy
MD, Flycast Media
Local and Voice Search Optimization
The antitrust ruling against Google is likely to reshape search by increasing competition and diversity in the search-engine market.
Focus on local SEO and voice-search optimization, as these areas are becoming increasingly important. Local search and voice search are likely to be less impacted by changes in the broader search-engine market. Optimizing for these can help you maintain visibility and connect with your target audience effectively.
Slavko Kovacevic
Head of SEO, Health Link SEO
Google’s Dominance Likely to Persist
The main focus of Judge Amit Mehta’s ruling was Google’s deals with Apple and other partners to make Google the preferred search provider in those companies’ channels. If Google can’t successfully appeal the ruling, then those deals may go away, but it’s unlikely that Google’s share of the search market will decline very much. Even if consumers have to jump through a couple of hoops to make Google the default search engine on their iPhones, those users will probably do what it takes to keep using Google. It’s still the best search engine by far.
But this ruling has turned up the heat on Google overall. The company’s tendency to downplay other providers in favor of its own products (e.g., online reviews and travel booking) will probably draw more attention, which may cause the company to think twice before putting its own services ahead of other offerings in the search results.
Scott Shrum
President & COO, Hennessey Digital
Increased Competition in Digital Advertising
The antitrust ruling against Google is a seismic shift for the search landscape and, consequently, for digital advertising. By forcing Google to potentially restructure its business model, we could see a ripple effect across the entire search ad ecosystem. If Google has to share the search pie, competition for ad space will definitely heat up. This means ad costs could rise as more advertisers fight for the same clicks. Plus, we might need to spread our ad budgets across different search engines, like Bing (and, of course, the emerging ones), making campaigns more complex.
Nayan Prakash
PPC Manager
Enhanced User Choice and Privacy
The antitrust ruling against Google is set to significantly alter the landscape of search by encouraging more competition and innovation among search engines. With stricter regulations, we may see the rise of alternative platforms that offer unique features tailored to user privacy and customization. As a result, users could benefit from a more diverse range of search options that challenge the dominance of Google.
I predict that this shift will not only enhance user choice but also force Google to adapt its strategies, perhaps by improving its services or addressing privacy concerns more vigorously. This evolving search environment could lead to a more balanced online ecosystem where smaller players gain traction.
Mike Drouin
Co-Founder, Digital Marketing Director, Gardening & Home Improvement Expert, Reefertilizer
Submit Your Answer
Would you like to submit an alternate answer to the question, “How will the antitrust ruling against Google reshape search? What’s one prediction you have for the potential fallout?”